Authenticity Over Inspiration

The Representation of Autism in Young Adult Literature

Sarah Guillemette

   Young adult literature has a powerful impact on adolescents because it helps them make sense of who they are, who they want to become, and how they understand the world around them. As Petrone (2015) explains in The Youth Lens, YAL is never simply passive entertainment; it shapes how teens understand adolescence itself and influences the stories they believe about who they can be (p. 5). Since identity formation is central to adolescence, the characters young people encounter in books greatly affects how they understand themselves. When students truly “see themselves” in literature, as Bishop describes through her mirrors-windows-doors metaphor reading becomes a form of self-affirmation (Bishop, 1990, p. 1). Gregory (2021) notes this effect as well, observing that “when students relate to and enjoy what they are reading, a powerful literacy emerges” (p. 25).

   However, when literature relies on narrow, stereotypical, or overly inspirational portrayals of marginalized identities, it can distort how adolescents understand themselves. This pattern is especially strong in the representation of disability, and autism in particular. YA fiction often presents autistic characters in two limited ways: either as heroic, saintlike figures with extraordinary abilities, what researchers call “supercrip narratives,” or as people who need to be corrected, or “fixed.” What’s missing is the space for autism simply to be, an identity that does not have to inspire others or be overcome. These portrayals shape how autistic teens come to view themselves and how adolescent readers understand autistic identity more broadly.

   Drawing on this research, this paper argues that Francisco Stork’s Marcelo in the Real World (2012), while compassionate and well-written, ultimately reflects many of these same limitations. The following analysis will first examine the broader trends in autism representation in YA literature, then explore how Marcelo in the Real World participates in these trends, and finally consider how these portrayals influence identity development in adolescents.

Authentic Representation

   Recently, Young Adult literature has included more characters with disabilities and cognitive differences, giving readers more authentic stories about diverse experiences. Some novels focus on physical disabilities and chronic conditions (Henley, 2021; Van Draanen, 2012), while others explore autism, communication differences, and cognitive disabilities, helping readers understand how neurodivergent teens experience school, relationships, and independence (Gervais, 2019; McGovern, 2015; Rozines, 2010; Haddon, 2012). Several authors also highlight the broader social pressures teens with disabilities face, including stigma and the need to advocate for themselves in unfamiliar environments (Gardner, 2017; Mazer & Lerangis, 2013; McGovern, 2015). More recent works continue expanding on this by exploring how disability intersects with identity and belonging (Khalilieh, 2024). Together, these texts move YA literature toward greater authenticity and inclusivity.

   Yet despite this progress, YA literature has long struggled to represent autism authentically. In many well-known novels such as Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time (2003), autism is framed through exceptional abilities, inspirational strength, or moral purity. These portrayals often rely on characters whose traits fit neatly within a narrow, “high-functioning” model of autism, reinforcing the idea that only certain autistic experiences are worth telling. As Rozema (2014) critiques, “Young adult fiction has thus far known only one child with autism: the high-functioning, hyperverbal savant with Asperger syndrome” (p. 28). This narrow pattern is fueled by what Joseph Shapiro (2016) calls the “supercrip narrative–” the “inspirational disabled person [...] glorified [...] lavishly lauded” (p. 16). These depictions may appear positive, but they flatten disabled characters into predictable roles.

   Instead of presenting autistic teens with varied personalities, struggles, or complexities, many novels showcase characters who transcend autism through brilliance or innocence. Cooper et al. (2023) warns that this “strengths-only” approach is also misleading: “While it is important to acknowledge autism as an identity and the strengths focus which can come along with this, autistic individuals also face multiple challenges” (p. 2). Authentic representation requires acknowledging both strengths and difficulty, not romanticizing or minimizing either one.

Representation in Marcelo in the Real World

   Stork’s Marcelo in the Real World (2012) participates in both sides of this trend. From the beginning, Marcelo is framed as spiritually exceptional: he meets with his Rabbi weekly, recites the Rosary, and regularly quotes scripture as his “special interest.” The author, Fransisco Stork, even admits that the Saints inspired Marcelo’s character, explaining, “When I was growing up in Mexico, I used to read about the lives of the saints— they provided a seed for Marcelo’s character” (Freitas, 2009). This framing positions Marcelo not as a typical autistic teen but as a stereotypical symbol of purity and goodness. Even his central plotline, his quest “to find the truth” after discovering a picture of an injured girl, mimics Christopher’s journey in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, reinforcing a familiar plot pattern.

   That being said, Marcelo does face real challenges in the novel, and Stork makes these struggles visible early on. Marcelo explains, “There are so many things I still have difficulties with… People say words I do not understand or their facial expressions are incomprehensible” (Stork, 2012, p. 23). But even these challenges are framed as deficits to be fixed rather than accepted as part of his identity. His father is a key figure in reinforcing this mindset, forcing Marcelo to work at his law firm to “learn to live in the real world” (p. 20) and insisting publicly that “there is nothing wrong with [Marcelo],” (p. 18) despite his obvious sensory and cognitive differences. Marcelo internalizes these harsh expectations, admitting, “Explanations about my condition are based on the assumption that there is something wrong with the way I am” (p. 55).

   These characterizations create a tension: Marcelo is either elevated as extraordinary or diminished as someone who must be corrected. This kind of “either-or-thinking” leaves little room for autistic characters to be shown as regular, complex teenagers. As Rozema (2014) argues, if YA literature wants to serve autistic readers well, “we would give them more than one role to play… heroes, villains, angels, demons, and everything in between” (p. 30). Marcelo’s portrayal ultimately shows how even well-intentioned stories can fall back on limited roles for autistic characters, displaying how there is an ongoing need for better representation in YAL.

How Representation Shapes Autistic Identity Development

   Because literature plays a central role in how teens make sense of identity, the consequences of narrow disability portrayals in YA are extensive. Cooper et al. (2023) found that “autistic young people who had a positive sense of their autism identity and felt solidarity with other autistic people had better psychological well-being and lower social anxiety” (p. 1). Their research makes clear that representation is not just about being seen, it directly shapes mental health, belonging, and self-image. When autistic readers encounter characters presented as saints, geniuses, or problems to be solved, they may internalize limiting or distorted ideas about what autism should look like.

   Marcelo in the Real World offers a concrete example of how these external portrayals influence identity and self-understanding. Throughout the novel, Marcelo struggles to figure out who he is in relation to the expectations placed on him. His father’s pressure to “function in the real world” (p. 20) frames Marcelo’s differences as failures to overcome, while his coworkers alternately label him as unusually naïve or unusually exceptional. Stuck between these interpretations, Marcelo begins to judge his own worth by how well he can imitate the neurotypical expectations placed on him. This pressure culminates late in the novel when he confides to his coworker, Jasmine, “I am not smart. I have been trained. It is training and concentration. Years of learning how to communicate” (p. 239). His reflection shows how external narratives (especially narrow ones) shape internal identity, influencing not only how others see autistic individuals but how autistic individuals come to see themselves.

   These portrayals illustrate what is at stake in striving for authentic representation. When YA frames autism as extraordinary, symbolic, or inspirational, autistic adolescents may feel like they must fit those stereotypical roles. Bishop (1990) reminds us that literature “reflects [experience] back to us, and in that reflection we can see our own lives… as part of the larger human experience” (p. 1). If that reflection is distorted, the identities teens build from it will also be distorted. In Marcelo’s case, the distorted reflection shapes not only the assumptions others make about him but also the way he learns to understand himself.

Conclusion

   Ultimately, the way autism is portrayed in YA literature matters because these stories help shape how young people understand identity, both their own and others’. When autistic characters are shown only as “inspiring” and “exceptional,” or as people who need to be corrected, or “fixed,” the everyday realities of autistic life are not represented, leaving readers with a narrow picture of what autism looks like. In contrast, when authors offer fuller and more authentic portrayals, autistic teens are more likely to see their experiences recognized, and non-autistic readers develop a more accurate and empathetic understanding. Because adolescents often turn to stories to make sense of themselves and the world around them, thoughtful representation has the power to support healthier, more grounded identity development for all readers.

Works Cited

Bishop, R. (1990). “Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors.” Perspectives: Choosing and Using Books for the Classroom, 6(3).

Freitas, D. (2009). Q & A with Francisco X. Stork. PublishersWeekly.com. https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/authors/interviews/article/722-q-a-with-f rancisco-x-stork.html

Forber-Pratt, A. J., Minotti, B. J., Burdick, C. E., Kate Brown, M., & Hanebutt, R. A. (2021). Exploring disability identity with adolescents. Rehabilitation Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/rep0000411

Gardner, W. (2017). You’re welcome, universe. Knopf Books for Young Readers. 

Gervais, A. (2019). The silence between us. Harpercollins Focus.

Gregory, C.G. (2021). From stacks to desks: A history of Young Adult Literature and the case for inclusion. In B. Maldonado (Ed). Arts integration and Young Adult Literature: Strategies to enhance academic skills and student voice. Rowman & Littlefield.

Haddon, M. (2003). The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime. W. Ross Macdonald School Resource Services Library.

Henley, A. (2021). A face for Picasso. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. Khalilieh, J. (2024). Something More. Tundra Books.

Mazer, H., & Lerangis, P. (2013). Somebody, please tell me who I am. Simon & Schuster Bfyr. 

McGovern, C. (2015). A step toward falling. HarperCollins.

Mcgovern, C. (2015). Say what you will. Harperteen, An Imprint Of Harpercollins Publishers.

Petrone, R., Sarigianides, S. T., & Lewis, M. A. (2015). The Youth Lens: Analyzing adolescence/ts in literary texts. Journal of Literacy Research, 46(4), 506–533. https://doi.org/10.1177/1086296x15568926

Rozema, R. (2014). The Problem of Autism in Young Adult Fiction. Language Arts Journal of Michigan, 30(1). https://doi.org/10.9707/2168-149x.2039

Rozines, J. (2010). Mindblind. Marshall Cavendish.

Schalk, S. (2016) Reevaluating the Supercrip. Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies 10(1).

Stork, F. X. (2012). Marcelo in the real world. Scholastic.

Van Draanen, W. (2012). The running dream. Random House Publishing Group.